Make or Zapier for forms, Sheets and Slack: which plan fits?
If hourly or two-hourly processing is acceptable, this job may fit Make Free under the assumptions below. The exact three-step Zapier design needs Professional. Faster handling, a separate work sheet and the full account’s usage determine the choice.

Official information checked on October 3, 2026. This guide combines documented facts and illustrative calculations. We have not run the scenario or Zap, measured delivery time or verified a checkout, renewal quote or real account bill.
Start with the same job
A freelancer or small team receives 100 new Google Forms submissions over a 30-day month, operates around the clock, writes each submission to a separate working Google Sheet, then posts one internal Slack channel message.
Make’s route is Google Forms Watch Responses → Google Sheets Add a Row → Slack Send a Message. Zapier’s route is Google Forms New Form Response → Google Sheets Create Spreadsheet Row → Slack Send Channel Message. These are one trigger and two ordinary actions. Make Forms, Sheets, Slack; Zapier Forms, Sheets, Slack.
Zapier requires Forms responses to be saved to a native Google Sheet. Keep that raw response sheet separate from the working destination sheet; native Forms logging is not a Zap action. Account access, connection permissions and Slack channel membership still need checking. Forms prerequisites.
The result is comparable, while the trigger timing differs. Make Watch Responses polls on a schedule. Zapier documents New Form Response as Instant. That label does not guarantee an end-to-end number of seconds, and we have not measured either route’s waiting time.
Where the Free plans stop
Make Free is USD0 with 1,000 credits per month, two active scenarios and a minimum scheduled interval of 15 minutes. One scenario can contain this trigger and both actions. Core starts at the 10,000-credit monthly tier and supports one-minute scheduling and unlimited active scenarios. Make plans.
One-minute scheduling is a technical setting, not proof that Core 10,000 covers a month of it. Under this guide’s model, every-minute operation for 30 days needs 43,200 checks + 200 action credits = 43,400 credits, beyond 10,000. We have no verified total price for the higher usage tier or extra credits that would cover it.
Zapier Free is USD0 with 100 tasks per month and unlimited Zaps, but each Zap has two steps: a trigger and one action. Professional supports multi-step Zaps and premium apps. Its generic polling interval is two minutes, versus Free’s 15 minutes; those intervals do not describe this Instant Forms trigger. Zapier plans.
The three selected Zapier app directory headings were not marked Premium at the check date. That is a directory observation, not a promise about every event or account. Make lists the selected modules without a paid-only restriction found in these sources. Confirm actual connector availability before relying on either plan.
Make: include the checks that find nothing
The official Make Academy documents Google Forms Watch Responses still consuming one credit on an empty scheduled check. This is official course evidence, not our own test or a Google Sheets Watch New Rows result. Forms check example.
Let P be scheduled checks and N be new submissions. Assume one trigger credit per check, two ordinary actions at one credit each per submission, and each submission retrieved once during the modeled month. Exclude extra pagination, additional trigger operations, initialization, manual tests, retries, catch-up work and other scenarios. Some modules have different or dynamic credit billing, so this model is specific to those assumptions. Credit examples.
P = 30 × 24 × 60 ÷ interval in minutes
Planned credits = P + 2N; N = 100
| Make interval | Checks P | Two actions for 100 records | Planned credits | Against Free’s 1,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15 minutes | 2,880 | 200 | 3,080 | Exceeds by 2,080 |
| 60 minutes | 720 | 200 | 920 | 80 remain |
| 120 minutes | 360 | 200 | 560 | 440 remain |
The 3,080 figure is planned demand that Free does not cover; it is not a claim that Free completes the excess. Even the 15-minute check baseline of 2,880 exceeds the cap before any submissions.
Hourly processing leaves little room. Two-hourly processing leaves more if that wait is acceptable. Configure retrieval limits for bursts and verify actual history; scheduling wait may approach the interval, with queue or error delays added. None of these totals or delays is a measured result.
The Academy action example calls its Slack module Create a Message, while current module documentation says Send a Message. Treat the course as billing evidence and confirm current event names in your account. Academy examples, current Slack modules.
Zapier: count successful actions and steps
For two successful ordinary actions on each submission, planned tasks = 100 × 2 = 200. Triggers and polling checks do not consume tasks; successful replayed actions can add tasks. We have excluded replays and other Zaps from the example. Task measurement.
The exact route exceeds Free’s 100-task cap and also requires a multi-step Zap because it has two actions. Splitting it into two Free Zaps still leaves 200 tasks across the account. Professional’s 750-task tier is the minimum practical paid tier for this design, leaving 550 before other usage. Step and tier limits.
Credits and tasks are different billing units. Comparing 920 with 200, or dividing each plan price by its unit allowance, does not establish which tool is better value.
Which plan fits the original requirement?
The following keeps the separate working sheet and Slack message for all 100 submissions. “Candidate” means the calculation and documented plan limits fit, subject to account access and actual usage.
| Plan and schedule | Planned usage | Fit for this exact job |
|---|---|---|
| Make Free, 15-minute polling | 3,080 credits | Exceeds 1,000; not covered |
| Make Free, 60 or 120 minutes | 920 or 560 credits | Candidate if waiting is acceptable and total usage fits |
| Make Core 10,000, 15 minutes | 3,080 credits | Candidate before other account usage |
| Zapier Free, Instant Forms | 200 tasks; trigger + two actions | Task cap and step limit both fail |
| Zapier Professional 750, Instant Forms | 200 tasks | Candidate; 550 tasks remain before other usage |
Make’s 15-minute and Zapier’s Instant routes do not promise the same delay. Choose an acceptable handling interval before deciding what the plan must cover.
Compare the price and the payment commitment
These are advertised USD amounts for the selected tiers, not a verified local checkout or renewal quote.
| Selected tier | Monthly payment | Annual monthly equivalent | Yearly amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Make Core, 10,000 credits/month | USD12 | USD9 | USD108, derived as 9 × 12 |
| Zapier Professional, 750 tasks/month | USD29.99 | USD19.99 | USD239.88, published annual amount |
Make’s monthly price comes from its pricing page; its advertised annual equivalent is corroborated by Make’s own-price comparison and credit documentation. USD108 is arithmetic from the displayed equivalent, not an observed annual charge; rounding of a displayed monthly equivalent may affect the final amount.
The official allocation rules make a specific Core exception: credits are allocated monthly even on an annual subscription. Do not apply the page’s general annual-pool description to this Core tier.
Zapier’s public pricing records specify Professional 750 at USD29.99 monthly or USD239.88 yearly; 239.88 ÷ 12 gives USD19.99. Annual billing pays for the year up front, rather than deducting the equivalent each month. Taxes, regional currency, discounts, checkout, renewal and exchange rates remain unverified.
A one-action Free Zap changes the design
If you accept the native Forms response sheet as the working sheet, you can remove the separate row-writing action and keep only Slack. For 100 successful notifications, the calculation is 100 tasks, a possible Zapier Free candidate if the exact event and account qualify.
That uses the entire 100-task allowance, with no room for other successful actions or replays. It also gives up the original requirement for a separate working destination. This is an alternative architecture, not evidence that the original two-action job fits Free.
Choose around the work you need
Evaluate Make Free when hourly or two-hourly handling is acceptable and the account has a buffer. Compare Core for this 15-minute design or when you need more active scenarios. Compare Zapier Professional when its Instant trigger or your existing operating setup justifies the commitment.
Before switching, confirm the connector events, raw and working sheets, burst retrieval, channel permissions, error recovery and total account usage. Record real runs before claiming latency, reliability, setup-time or cost savings. We have no measured winner.
Check Make’s current plans and check Zapier’s current plans. For more detail, read our Make Free guide and complete automation cost guide.
These are ordinary official plan links; an active commission-tracking link has not been confirmed here. Our affiliate disclosure explains the site’s policy.